Balaton WebPicnic Supplies

Motorbike Helmet Laws, Human Behaviour & The Organ Donor Effect

It is a fiercely debated topic among bikers, politicians and recently the people of Missouri.

It’s a ‘freedom of choice’ debate for many, questioning why the legislators feel they know what individuals need better than themselves. It is also a scale issue, how extensive should laws be to protect life and where should the line be drawn? Laws state that an individual is not allowed to intentionally end their own life, helmet laws attempt to reduce the risk of death, how far will legislators go to protect life and what effect will this have on the quality of life for the individual?

Of course it isn’t that simple, we’re not all only individuals but together we make up a society and sometimes the actions of individuals can have positive and negative effects on other individuals and on wider society.

So the debate widens to consider costs and benefits to society. I’m not going to go into this area in detail because most of the costs and benefits have already been widely discussed previously. Considerations include the immediate loss of life to a rider who is involved in a fatal accident, any pillion rider who is unfortunate enough to be involved, and any other parties who are involved in the accident. Pillion riders, like passengers in car accidents form a sad statistic as the accident is normally completely outside of their control, yet they bear the same consequences. Considerations also include hospital services, police investigations, legal inquiries, and road clean up and repair work. Individual freedom of choice should hold strong consideration, and the fact that the use or non-use of amotorcycle helmet doesn’t directly effect the health of anyone else other than themselves (ignoring the Organ Donor Effect).

The Organ Donor Effect – Mitigating the cost of motorcycle accidents on society? It isn’t a new concept, but one that has received revived publicity lately following the Missouri motorbike helmet law saga. For me the relationship between motorcycle accidents and organ donations is interesting because people will use the same relationship to argue both for and against crash helmet laws. You can even find motorcyclists citing the relationship in their arguments against motorcycle helmet laws. This multi use of the same argument is interesting, any use of the argument is in fact bizarre because the effect implies different values on the lives of motorcyclists compared to humans on the organ donation waiting list. Are not the lives of all humans valued equally? Of course they are not, if they were politicians would not be sending our young men to war but be going themselves, but that is off topic. So what is the Organ Donor Effect? Statistics show a relationship exists between motorbike helmet use and the number of fatal motorcycle accidents from head trauma. Compulsory helmet laws increase helmet use, causing a corresponding decrease in rider fatalities. The Organ Donor Effect is the statistical relationship between a decrease in head trauma related motorcycle rider fatalities and a corresponding decrease in healthy organ donations. Motorcycle riders tend to be young and healthy and have an above average likelihood of providing healthy organs following death from head trauma. Statistics have shown that for every motorcycle accident fatality from head trauma, 0.33 deaths have been delayed on the organ waiting list. Note that it is not a one to one relationship, but rather three riders have to die to save one person in need of an organ.

The argument against helmet laws citing the Organ Donor Effect tends to be along the lines of that the enactment of crash helmet laws will reduce the number of organ donations every year causing a corresponding increase in the number of deaths on the organ waiting list.

An argument for helmet laws citing the Organ Donor Effect is statistically stronger, consider that for every three biker deaths, only one persons life in need of an organ will be saved (extended). So unless the lives of bikers are somehow less important than everyone else, the Organ Donor Effect as an argument for, or against motorbike helmet legislation is irrelevant.

Butterfly Effect – Actions can have reactions further away than may initially be considered. The Organ Donor Effect when considering motorcycle helmet legislation is an interesting example of a Butterfly Effect. The use of helmets don’t only effect those immediately involved in a motorcycle accident, but can also effect third parties which you would not immediately consider – those on organ donor waiting lists. But just because there is a relationship, doesn’t mean it is an important relationship and doesn’t mean that it deserves to be considered in the debate.

More serious helmet law considerations should be around half helmets and other minimalistic helmets which offer questionable protection. If these helmet styles qualify as adequate protection under law, but do not actually adequately protect the human head in a motorcycle accident. It begs the question of whether there is any point to having the helmet laws in the first place.

In most debates that consider individual choice versus legislative control I personally favour individual choice.

But in this debate I considered two ideas, firstly whether motorcycle helmets are a good thing for people to wear and secondly whether individuals have the capability to choose for themselves uninfluenced by other people. In this situation after much thought I decided that given the choice I would vote in favour of compulsory helmet laws for all ages. Because when helmet use becomes the norm there is no longer a question of whether it is cooler to ride with or without a helmet, everyone just wears one. Ideally I would like there to be no helmet laws and every individual able to make his or her own choice, but unfortunately I don’t believe the individuals would be able to make their own choice, but rather be influenced too heavily by media, other riders, and the individual’s perception of what is ‘cool’. Peer pressure is commonly considered a child and teenager issue but I believe it is simply a human characteristic. To want to do as others do, the desire to be accepted, desire to fit in, desire to stand out. I believe that the majority of riders given the option of wearing a helmet or not would base their decision on what they believe others would think of them (what image they will portray). It is this unfortunate human characteristic that moves me in support of compulsory motorbike helmet laws.

If everyone was not influenced by everyone else, then people would be capable of thinking for themselves and all self respecting individuals would wear motorcycle crash helmets anyway.

James Lamport-Burr is a full time Financial Accountant and part-time Internet Marketer. Who’s passions include business, stock markets, sports and making the most of life. James is an avid motorcyclist and currently rides a 1996 MuZ Skorpion Tour.

MotorcycleHelmetCritic.com
For Motorcycle Helmet information including how they actually protect your head in an accident. Plus motorcycle crash helmets and helmet accessories.

About the Author

Jokari Black Expandable Cargo Cooler

Car Seat/Cooler HANGER HOLDER CD Organizer Backpack J89 $0.99

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $13.50

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $9.21

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $9.54

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $9.49

NEW Sunshine Kids Car Travel Pal Organizer and Cooler $30.00

Car Seat/Cooler HANGER HOLDER CD Organizer Backpack J89 $5.99

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $14.75

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $9.49

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $9.26

3 in 1 Chair/Car Seat/Backpack Cooler Organizer/1097Bk $22.95

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $11.09

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $9.21

Cargo Organizer, Soft-Sided Cooler Bag W/Adjustable Car $21.25

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $9.21

Car Back Seat Backpack Organizer with a Cooler Bag New $11.09

NEW Sunshine Kids Car Travel Pal Organizer and Cooler $29.99

Jokari Grocery Tote and Car Trunk Organizer, Black $11.90 Jokari Expandable Cargo Tote Tote groceries, sports gear and even plants safely without things tumbling around in the trunk of your car. The handy Expandable Cargo Tote has 3 ample sections for organizing and carrying items in your trunk or the back of your SUV. When you’re not on the road, you can use the carryall for extra storage at home. Organize auto and home such as groceries, kids’ ac…

Thermos TRVL Insulated Front Seat Organizer, Black $9.58 Thermos T1100104 Car Organizer T1100104 1270…

car trunk organizer & cooler $49.95 A must-have for neat freaks, our car organizer keeps you well-prepared on the road. Ideal for storing items for sports games, picnics, vacations or trips to the grocery store, our durable car trunk organizer has three large sections. A sturdy cooler fits in one section to keep food and drinks cold while you’re on the road. The other sections are great for storing car repair items, gym clothes, umb…

AutoCool with Bonus Car Cup Organizer Use the sun to keep your car cool We’ve all experienced it: you park your car on a hot summer day. When you return to your vehicle, you open the door and immediately feel like you’re in an oven. The inside is hot and uncomfortable. The seats are sticky and the steering wheel feels like it’s on fire. Not a pleasant way to enter your vehicle. The AutoCool uses sunlight to keep your car cool while yo…

FRIO Large Insulin Cooler Wallet FRIO keeps insulin safe even in hot climates. Choose the product size that is right for you: Large Wallet-Ideal for carrying various combinations of pens, vials and cartridges as follows: a. 4 x insulin injection pens – either pre-filled disposable pens or refillable pens (not incl.) or b. 15 x 3ml or 1.5ml cartridges (not incl.) or c. 6 x 10ml vials of insulin and syringes (not incl.) Inn…

JLR Smart Gifts CAR BUDDY 12 Pack travel/Organizer $17.00 …

Trunk Organizer with Cooler $29.95 Keep groceries picnic supplies or camping gear secured during transport Cooler for keeping perishables fresh during long drivesCompact when not in use to preserve trunk space28″ W x 13″ H x 8 1/4″ D…

Car Trunk Organizer $25.00 Keep in your car to organize groceries, school books, or traveling necessities. -Rugged polyester -Expandable to over 2 feet -Three dividers -Four mesh open pockets -Carrying handles….

Wagan EL2296 10.5 Liter Personal Fridge and Warmer $64.95 The Wagan 10.5 Liter Personal Thermo-Electric Fridge/Warmer is large enough for one 12 cans of soda. It has fast cooling capacity of 40°F-45°F below room temperature. It cools to as low as 32°F and heats up to 140°F….

Rugged Ridge 13551.15 Rear Seat Organizer and Center Console Trash Bin for Jeep Wrangler JK 2007-2010 $26.94 REAR SEAT ORGANIZER, RUGGED RIDGE, JEEP WRANGLER (JK) 07-10…

Sunshine Kids Car Organizer & Cooler $29.99 Keep toys and books handy with adjustable dividers in main pocket for customized storage and organization. Versatile, water resistant main compartment can be used as a cooler with ice to keep drinks cold. Zip top closure keeps items secure when carrying. Two insulated drink holder pockets in front. Shoulder strap for easy transportation. Pockets on both sides so both kids can store their favorite item. Dimensions are 10.5” W x 9.25” H x 14” D.

Sunshine Kids Organizer and Cooler $29.99 Sunshine Kids Organizer and Cooler

Trunk Organizer and Cooler set $46.8 Trunk Organizer and Cooler set

Car Entertainment Organizer by Talus, Black $14.49 Car Entertainment Organizer by Talus

Golf Car Organizer $79 Golf Car Organizer. Manufacturer: Classic Accessories. Brand: Classic Accessories. Part Number: 72677. UPC: 052963726770

Mercury 8174 Portable Cooler with Organizer $45.5 Portable cooler with organizer has solid black lining and comes with main compartment and double zippered U opening. Front zippered accessory pocket with cell phone holder slash pocket and key ring. Interior clear vinyl zippered pocket and end mesh slash pocket. Front small zippered mesh pocket reinforced handle and detachable adjustable shoulder strap.

COCOON INNOVATIONS / GRIDIT ORGANIZER CAR VISOR / CPG30BK $34.88 COCOON INNOVATIONS – GRIDIT ORGANIZER CAR VISOR – CPG30BK

Car Entertainment Organizer by Talus $14.49 Pack large quantities of entertainment accessories into one auto organizer. The Car Entertainment Organizer gives you the benefit of enjoying your drive with fun and entertainment. This auto organizer optimizes car storage space. Made of heavy-duty packcloth material with reinforced stitching this auto organizer has a larger lifespan. It has 7 pockets for the entire car media storage and entertainment management in your car. Two center pockets store about 10 CDs with cases or a CD player and game discs. Store other entertainment items like cards, toys, etc. in the smaller mesh pockets. The bottommost pocket can hold bigger items like books, VHS tapes, etc. With the help of a removable cord the auto organizer stays intact and close to the car seat. As an added benefit for travel, the auto organizer is accompanied with a compact tissue holder that is a perfect storage unit for any rectangular tissue box. The black colored auto organizer looks contemporary and complements the other car accessories.Features: • Heavy-duty packcloth construction • Reinforced stitching for extra durability • 2 center pockets for CDs, games or CD player • 1 pocket that holds standard tissue box • Mesh pockets for smaller items • Removable cord keeps organizer close to the seat • Color: BlackSize: 19 5/8″tall x 11″wide x 3 1/2″deep

Family Car Organizer – by Tuffo – CAR-001 $36.99 Imagine a beautiful sight: the backseat of your car - and it’s clean! This Family Car Organizer will keep your car or van neat and tidy, while helping to eliminate backseat boredom! This handy organizer has adjustable dividers, a removable, reinforced lid, and flip up sides. This organizer is made from a durable, easy to clean nylon fabric, and secures easily to the seat belt for security. This organizer also has a adjustable carry strap, so it’s easy to transport from car to house! Finally, a place for snacks, books, crayons and more!  This item ships directly from the manufacturer. Product usually arrives in 2-8 business days, depending on destination, including order processing and shipping. APO/FPO shipping unavailable

Organizer $9.76 Organizer

Auto Sun Visor Car Organizer $4.99 The Auto sun Visor Organizer is the key to any vehicle organization! This organizer fits literally all auto/truck visors. The organizer features a large top zipper compartment perfect for documents such as registration and insurance info, a smaller velcro pocket great for your driver’s license money credit cards, your iPod and more. This organizer also holds two pens in an elastic holster, two additional deep pockets for sun glasses or a wallet and 3super soft cd holsters to your favorite cd’s will not scratch.

Multicolored Kids Car Organizer Tote $14.99 A car organizer can help make your car trips less stressful by keeping your essentials organized and within your reach. Store toys snacks and games in one convenient organizer so kids can reach what they want without your help. It s a toy box a snack bar and with a quick zip and flip the top converts to a game table that is sturdy enough to draw or play on. Outside it s thoughtfully designed with identical sides to hold games CD players books and other items. The front has a drink holder holders for individual pencils pens markers or crayons and a pouch with velcro to secure items. Two included adjustable dividers lets kids organize separate their gear. This ingenious design helps to prevent squabbles by giving each child his her own space. The padded sides insulate the contents for cool drinks wherever you are. The convenient carry strap provides hands free portability to and from the car and the whole unit converts to a fun tote for outings. Your kids will love it!

Car Entertainment Organizer – by Talus – ENTERTAIN $11.99 Reduce all that car clutter with our Entertainment Organizer! This multifunctional organizer attaches around your headrest posts so you and your kids can effortlessly reach your music, videos, games, or whatever! There are seven pockets that include 2 center pockets for holding 10 of your favorite CDs, DVDs or 14 cassettes. Mesh pockets can hold your smaller items like gum, lip gloss, or crayons. And you can place a standard box of tissues in the top pocket for when you need them. There is no reason to be distracted while driving with all your items neatly organized and within reach. No assembly required. This item ships directly from Stacks and Stacks. Product usually arrives in 2-8 business days, depending on destination, including order processing and shipping.

Back Seat Car Organizer – by Talus – KIDSBSO-BL $29.99 Keep the backseat or trunk of your car in order with this kids’ car organizer! Made of pack cloth, this car seat organizer was designed with rugged construction in mind, including padded sides to insulate contents and a sturdy lid that becomes a tray for eating or playing. The backseat organizer features adjustable dividers to organize items inside, while 8 outside pockets, including dual drink-holders, keep snacks, books, and CD players safe from breakage and spillage. Includes a handy shoulder strap for transportation. This item ships directly from Stacks and Stacks. Product usually arrives in 2-8 business days, depending on destination, including order processing and shipping.

BabyBeeCool UCSC001 Universal Car Seat Cooler $81 Made of an insulated fabric sold along with reusable ice blocks that are placed within lined pockets of the padding. This cooling protection lasts up to 10 hours in the extreme heat The BabyBeeCool Car Seat Cooler Pad was designed in the heat of the Arizona desert. Interior car temperatures can reach in excess of 185 degrees Fahrenheit Using the BabyBeeCool Car Seat Cooler Pad your car seat could be up to 100 degrees cooler No more of those hot seats your child refuses to sit in No more burning metal buckles snaps fasteners and safety hazards The universal design easily fits all baby car seats Also functions as a handy cooler for bottles or other foods Designed with shoulder straps to make it easy to also carry your baby

Sierra Designs The Organizer $34.95 No more losing gear, know where it all is with the Sierra Design The Organizer is a hanging, multi-section organizer that stows small items, headlamps, batteries, paperbacks and other items found inside a tent. The Organizer also hangs outside the tent from a tree or roof rack while car camping

Sunshine Kids Mommy & Me Car Organizer $19.99 Back seat organizer is the perfect companion for moms-on-the-go. Now you can take essentials with you or keep them handy in the car. 4 various sized pockets including an insulated bottle holder. Stylish grey and black fabric design. Unzips on both sides to hang flat from headrest. Organize toys and essentials for baby while in or out of the car. 15.25” W x 14”H.

Car Seat Organizer – Swing Away™ Extra Large Organizer $17.49 The Swing Away™ Driver Organizer by Talus keeps everything within an arm’s reach and neatly organized so you can better concentrate on the road. The multiple pockets offer front-seat access to maps, CDs, phones, documents, magazines, PDAs, glasses, game players, and more. Place beverages, moist towelettes and other necessities in the two mesh side pockets. The Swing Away™ is uniquely designed to swing out of the way when the passenger seat is occupied. Constructed of 600-denier packcloth with adjustable strap fasteners, this car organizer was built to withstand years of daily use. Features: • 600-denier packcloth construction • Multiple pockets for storing travel necessities • Mesh pockets for even more storage • Specially designed drink holder • Swings out when passenger seat is occupied • Adjustable strap fasteners • Color: BlackSize: 9″tall x 18″wide x 4″deepAlso, see the Smaller Version .

Classic Accessories Golf Car Organizer – Black $62.99 The Classic Accessories Golf Car Organizer conveniently gives easy access to your golf essentials. Durable, Weather Protected shell. Large zip-close padded main compartment with tee holders, two pencil sleeves, and stuff pocket. Four padded compartments with rip-and-grip tabs for cell phones, maps, etc. Two zippered storage pockets including integrated cigar holder. Stores up to three golf balls in a special easy-access pocket.

Cargo Organizer – by Jokari – 6425 $19.99 This cargo organizer is convenient for transporting groceries and holding auto accessories. Choose from one, two or three compartments just by expanding or minimizing the size of this auto organizer. The durable construction and handy front mesh pockets hold frequently used items such as maps, tissues, flashlights and more! Use this car organizer in the trunk or backseat and even your home. This cargo carry-all will go everywhere with you and organize all your necessary car items. Folds flat when not in use. This item ships directly from Stacks and Stacks. Product usually arrives in 2-8 business days, depending on destination, including order processing and shipping.

Driver Organizer by High Road – Pink $9.95 Remove the clutter from your car. The Driver Organizer hangs in the front seat, and with several conveniently-sized pockets, makes the perfect addition to your mobile office.